| Recipe | Inn | Rating |
| Amish Wedding Steak | Patchwork Quilt Country Inn | 4.3 stars |
| Au Gratin Potatoes | Terrace Inn & Restaurant | -- |
| Beef Burgundy | Blue Belle Inn B&B | -- |
| Blackberry Brandied Chicken | Blue Belle Inn B&B | -- |
| Braised Beef Short Ribs | The Villas at Gervasi Vineyard | -- |
| Buttermilk Pecan Chicken | Patchwork Quilt Country Inn | -- |
| Chef Dan's Smoked Ribs | Elkhorn Inn & Theatre | -- |
| Cherry St. Collard Salad | House on Cherry St | -- |
| Chicken Carbonnara | Blue Belle Inn B&B | -- |
| Cornish Pasty | Rivertown Inn | -- |
| Creole Stuffed Summer Squash | Murski Homestead B&B | -- |
| Duck Impersonating Ravioli With Butternut Squash Puree And Pistachio Butter | The Villas at Gervasi Vineyard | -- |
| Espresso Crusted Beef Strip With Cumin Parsnip Puree | The Historic Afton House Inn | -- |
| Fettuccine Alla Gaby | Casa Bella Inn | -- |
| Fruited Loin Of Pork | Arbor Hill Inn | -- |
| Grandison Candle-light Chicken Dinner | The Grandison Inn at Maney Park | -- |
| Green Mountain Inn Chicken | Green Mountain Inn | -- |
| Grilled Seared Cinnamon And Cumin Pork Roast | Timber Cove Inn | -- |
| Haddock De Journee | Compass Rose Inn | -- |
| Heaven And Earth Soup | Blue Belle Inn B&B | 5 stars |
| Mama-san Carol's Black Bean And Chicken Chili | Sherwood Forest B&B | -- |
| Manny's Cuban Black Bean Soup | The Edward Harris House B&B Inn | -- |
| Maple Baked Pork Chops | Quail Hollow Inn | -- |
| Maple Mustard Chicken | Austin Hill Inn | -- |
| Mariniated Venison Loin W/ Grilled Peaches & Garden Vegetables | Grafton Inn | -- |
| Mediterranean Bouillabaisse | Grafton Inn | -- |
| Pan-seared Loin of Pork With Derry Apple Relish | Stonewall Jackson Inn B&B | -- |
| Pork Pie | Austin Hill Inn | -- |
| Roasted Pork And Swiss Cheese Filled Cannelloni With Red & White Sauces | Blue Belle Inn B&B | -- |
| Salmon With Cream Caper Sauce | The Grandison Inn at Maney Park | -- |
| Seasoned Pork And Parmesan Stuffed Pumpkins | Blue Belle Inn B&B | 5 stars |
| Shredded Chicken In Green Sauce | Murski Homestead B&B | -- |
| Shrimp And Spinach Casserole | College Club | -- |
| Stuffed Mushroom Soup | A Grand Inn-Sunset Hill House | -- |
| Sweet Potato And Black Bean Chili | Stonewall Jackson Inn B&B | -- |
| Sweet Potato Encrusted Rockfish | Smithfield Station | -- |
| Turkey Chili | Austin Hill Inn | -- |
| Tuscan Style Steak With Arugula And Parmesan | College Club | -- |
| Vegetable Pasta With A Wine Viognier Sauce | Eagles Nest Winery & Cottage | -- |
| Wild Mushroom & Spinach Risotto With Grafton Smoked Cheddar | Grafton Inn | 5 stars |
